Home

Introduction
Bhutan: At A Glance

Background

• Nationality Issues 

State Dept. Reports

AI Reports 

Other HR Reports 

Picture Gallery

NA Resolutions

International Resol. 

Documents 

Voluntary Emigrations

News Update 

International News 

Testimonies 

Books on Bhutan 

The Camps 
 Ethnic Cleansing: Distinct National Identity and the Refugees from Southern Bhutan

| Index | Over View | Demographic | Nationality | Loosing Citizenship | First Census |  NOC |  Arrest & Torture | South Today | Camps | Diplomatic TimeLine | Nationality Law | Marriage Act |

 

Marriage Incentives and the Marriage Act

In 1988 the government reported 11,442 marriages between Bhutanese and non-nationals during the preceding 20 years.[63] A breakdown of statistics on these marriages is not provided, yet it is safe to assume that a good percentage involve southern Bhutanese.  Given the strict cultural and caste restrictions on marriage, spouses are commonly sought outside home communities, often in Nepal or India.  A longstanding approach of the government to discourage such foreign marriages and promote integration is an incentive (raised to Nu. 10,000 in 1989) for intermarriage between southern and northern Bhutanese.[64]

Opposite this incentive stand stiff penalties for marriage to foreigners laid out in the 1980 Marriage Act (reproduced in Appendix 2).  Under this act, a Bhutanese citizen who marries a foreigner is denied government assistance in the form of land, seeds, loans, livestock, and health benefits.  If working for the government, promotion is denied from the day of marriage, and removal from service is mandatory for workers in the defense department or Foreign Ministry.  All assistance from the government for education is denied and any expenses incurred to the day of marriage must be refunded.

Refugees contend this act is discriminatory because of the disparate impact on Southerners due to the large proportion of the foreign marriages from their communities.  Further, they charge that the act is only implemented in the south, citing northern high ranking officials with foreign spouses who have received promotions and foreign postings in spite of the law.[65]The King suggested that non-nationals married to Bhutanese... could be granted special resident permit [sic].  They would also be entitled to health, education and other social benefits extended to citizens of the country.[66]  There are no indications that any such permits have actually been issued.

No Objection Certificates

  The government of Bhutan states "to ensure that all bona fide Bhutanese children received the first preference for admission in schools, a No Objection Certificate was made essential" and these "would not be issued to those students who have been involved in anti-national activities and to children of illegal immigrants."[67] No Objection Certificates were also required "for the release of cheques to farmers for the sale of their cash crops."[68] The government explained "the money due to the owners of these cash crops is merely frozen and not confiscated" and "will be released once the current disturbed situation is resolved."[69] Refugees report that No Objection Certificates were virtually impossible for southern Bhutanese to obtain.  The impact of No Objection Certificates is still strongly felt by refugee farmers who had to flee before collecting payment for years of work, or by students who lost years from their education.

 Green Belt

The government introduced a project to create a one kilometer wide belt of forest along the border, "probably for security reasons rather than for environmental ones since Bhutan is already richly-forested."[70]  The government's plan, involving the displacement of thousands of people from some of the most fertile land in Bhutan, was not met with favor from international donors and was quickly dropped.  

Next Page

|Introduction | Bhutan At a Glance | Background | Nationality | State Dept. Reports| Amnesty Reports | Picture Gallery | NA Resolutions | Human Rights Reports |International Resolutions  | Documents | Voluntary Emigration | News Update | International News Clippings | Testimonies  | Books on Bhutan  | The Camps |

© Bhutan Home Page. All rights reserved. Designed 
and maintained by Steve Allen