A prisoner of conscience held since 1989 continued to serve a life
sentence. At least 30 possible prisoners of conscience were detained. Some
120 political prisoners were sentenced to up to 15 years' imprisonment.
Many of those detained were reportedly tortured or ill-treated.
The 76th National Assembly voted in June to
approve an edict by King Jigme Singye Wangchuck transferring executive
powers to a six-member cabinet to be elected every five years.
The Druk National Congress (DNC) and the United
Front for Democracy (UFD), two political organizations in exile in Nepal,
continued their campaigning activities throughout the year, demanding a
democratic system of government and greater respect for human rights in
Bhutan.
Meetings of officials from Bhutan and Nepal
were held in Thimphu in May, October and November aimed at reviving talks
between the two governments on the fate of more than 90,000 mostly
Nepali-speaking people from southern Bhutan living in refugee camps in
eastern Nepal (see previous Amnesty International Reports).
In August a statement by the Chairman of the un
Sub-Commission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of
Minorities encouraged the governments of Bhutan and Nepal to set up an
impartial verification process for the people in the refugee camps in
Nepal and to make more effective and urgent efforts to negotiate their
return.
In January, 219 civil servants and employees of
government corporations were compulsorily retired as a result of a
resolution adopted by the National Assembly in 1997. This was interpreted
to be a discriminatory practice aimed at Nepali-speaking people from
southern Bhutan, many of whom were relatives of people living in the
refugee camps in eastern Nepal. At least 23 school students, aged between
seven and 21, whose relatives had been arrested for supporting the
pro-democracy movement, were expelled from school in eastern Bhutan.
Tek Nath Rizal, a prisoner of conscience, spent
his ninth year in prison (see Amnesty International Report 1994).
At least 30 possible prisoners of conscience
were detained, most on suspicion of being members or supporters of the
dnc. They were detained under the National Security Act (nsa) 1992.
Rongthong Kunley Dorji, leader of the dnc and
the ufd, was released on bail in India, while awaiting the outcome of
extradition proceedings to Bhutan (see Amnesty
International Report 1998).
As of early December, 120 political prisoners
arrested during 1997 in the east (see Amnesty
International Report 1998) had been tried under the NSA and
sentenced to up to 15 years' imprisonment. Among them were Thinley Oezer,
a senior monk of the Nyingmapa tradition of Mahayana Buddhism, and several
other monks and religious teachers. Thinley Oezer was sentenced to eight
years' imprisonment. His trial may have fallen short of international fair
trial standards.
Many of those detained on suspicion of being
DNC sympathizers were reportedly tortured or ill-treated. Methods included
chepuwa, a form of torture where the thighs are compressed
between two objects such as bamboo sticks, and severe beatings. Needup
Phuntsho, a 19-year-old pupil who had been expelled from school in March,
was reportedly tortured by members of the Royal Bhutan Police following
his arrest in Thimphu in July.
Amnesty International continued to appeal for
the immediate and unconditional release of Tek Nath Rizal; for political
prisoners to be released unless promptly charged with a recognizably
criminal offence; and for fair trials for all political prisoners. The
organization also appealed for an end to torture and ill-treatment.
In November an Amnesty International delegation
visited the country and met the King and Chairman of the Council of
Ministers and Minister of Foreign Affairs, Lyonpo Jigme Thinley, to
discuss the organization's concerns and make recommendations for the
protection of human rights. The delegates visited Mongar and Tashigang
districts in the east and Sarbhang district in the south